Lucia in a rust-coloured shirt and glasses and Jason in a floral shirt and amber sunglasses stand among palm trees at golden hour in GTA 6 key art
News · From the desk

GTA 6 Scores 99 on Metacritic, Level With Ocarina of Time as the Highest Rated Game Ever

+5 XP for Sharing

GTA 6 sits on 99 at Metacritic, level with Ocarina of Time at the top of the all-time list. Of the first 147 PS5 reviews, 118 were perfect scores and the lowest was 80. Here is what that number proves, and what it does not.

Quick take
  • The review embargo lifted at 6 am ET on Wednesday, November 18, and Metacritic counted 164 critic reviews that day for a score of 99.
  • That ties The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, which holds its 99 from 22 reviews.
  • Of the first 147 PS5 reviews, 118 gave a perfect score. The lowest score in the first wave was 80.
  • The complaints are narrow: twitchy driving at speed, cash targets in the story and a romance Jason Schreier calls “a little bit flat”.

The Claim on the Table: 99, Level With Ocarina

The embargo lifted at 6 am ET on Wednesday, November 18, the date reported back in October. Metacritic put GTA 6 at 99 with the first 164 critic reviews lodged. On November 19 its PS5 listing shows 99 from 157 reviews and its Xbox Series X listing 99 from 14. Counts move as late reviews are filed, so any total is a snapshot with a date on it.

A 99 puts GTA 6 level with The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, which holds its 99 from 22 reviews. The sample is the interesting part. Roughly seven times as many critics had to agree this time, and they did.

The Metacritic listing for Grand Theft Auto VI on PS5, showing a Metascore of 99, the Must-Play badge, Universal Acclaim based on 100 critic reviews and a user score marked tbd
The PS5 listing at 100 critic reviews: a 99, the Must-Play badge and a user score still marked tbd. The review count has kept climbing since. Metacritic

What the Scorecards Add Up To

// The review ledger

Figures as published on November 18 and 19. They will keep moving.

MeasureFigure
Metacritic score99
Reviews counted on November 18164
Perfect scores, first 147 PS5 reviews118
Lowest score, first wave80
Ocarina of Time99 from 22 reviews
Second score aggregator98 average, every critic recommends

Four in five critics gave it full marks. That is not a normal spread, even for Rockstar.

Four Critics, Four Ways of Saying It

Luke Reilly scored it 10 out of 10 on a standard PS5 and called it “the single most impressive video game I have ever played”. Tamoor Hussain gave it 10 on PS5 Pro and described “an astonishing open world action game”. Jason Schreier of Bloomberg, who has not finished the story, calls it “a masterpiece of a video game” and Rockstar’s best. Keza MacDonald of the Guardian needed 70 hours to reach the credits, and our how long to beat guide has the full range of finish times.

None of this was rushed out. Former Rockstar North developer Obbe Vermeij said back in 2024 that the studio would only ship when it was fully satisfied, a line GTA 6 Wiki covered at the time. Two delays later, the scorecards say he read it correctly.

The Complaints Are Narrow but Real

The ledger has a debit column. Fast driving is hard to control for some reviewers. A few points in the story ask you to earn a set amount before it moves on, which our money guide covers. Schreier finds the romance “a little bit flat” and some story missions “truly preposterous”, and several reviewers still put the story of Red Dead Redemption 2 ahead.

Performance drew less fire than expected. The game runs at 30 frames per second on every console. Hussain saw dips on PS5 Pro only in six-star chases, and Reilly reports a smooth run without bugs on a standard PS5. The measured figures are in our Digital Foundry tech review article.

What the Reviews Settle for Players

The reviews also close several open questions. The story has five chapters and more than one ending. Completed missions cannot be replayed, and there are 15 manual save slots. The wanted level goes to six stars, fuel can run out, and finish times run from 42 hours to close to 120.

A hand holds up a sealed PS5 case of Grand Theft Auto VI, with the PEGI 18 badge and a note reading Game download code, no disc included
A boxed PS5 copy of GTA 6. The case carries the PEGI 18 badge and says it holds a download code with no disc inside. Retail photo

Discussion

Comments · GTA 6 reviews: 99 on Metacritic

No comments yet.

Loading comments…