GTA 6 holds a 99 from critics and a 5.6 user score on Metacritic, from 80,720 ratings on November 22. About half of those ratings are positive, 44 per cent are negative and very little sits between. The store ratings tell a different story.
- User ratings opened on Metacritic on November 20. On November 22 the score is 5.6, “Mixed or Average”, from 80,720 ratings.
- The split is 49 per cent positive, 7 per cent mixed and 44 per cent negative.
- The low scores name the 30 frames per second cap, the story and the life you lead between jobs.
- On the PlayStation Store, where only buyers can rate, the game stood at 4.84 out of 5 on November 21.
The Claim on the Table: A 5.6 Next to a 99
User ratings opened on Metacritic on November 20, the day after launch. A day later the user score stood at 5.6, which the site labels “Mixed or Average”, from 60,692 ratings. On the morning of November 22 it is still 5.6, now from 80,720. The critic score beside it has not moved from 99, and our reviews article has that side of the ledger. These figures change by the hour, so each one here carries its date.

The Split Behind the Average
// The ratings ledger
Figures as shown on November 22 unless a date says otherwise. They keep moving.
| Measure | Figure |
|---|---|
| Critic score | 99 |
| User score | 5.6, “Mixed or Average” |
| User ratings counted | 80,720 |
| Positive | 49 per cent (39,695) |
| Mixed | 7 per cent (5,754) |
| Negative | 44 per cent (35,271) |
| PlayStation Store rating, November 21 | 4.84 out of 5, about 170,000 ratings |
An average of 5.6 describes a middling game. The split says almost nobody thinks that: more than nine ratings in ten sit at one end or the other. That is the shape of an argument, and an average hides it.
What the Zero Scores Say
Three complaints carry most of the low ratings. The first is the cap of 30 frames per second on every console, which our Digital Foundry tech review article measures. The second is the story, which some players did not get on with. The third is the life the game asks you to lead between jobs: the house, the routines and the relationship at the centre of it.
One zero posted on November 22 calls it a “relationship simulator and not a GTA game”. A ten from the same day reads “The most amount of fun I’ve had in a recent video game”. Both are short, and both are typical. The opening hours are slow by design, and our how long to beat guide shows how much game sits behind them.

The Counter Move Hit Zelda
Fans of GTA 6 answered in kind. The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time is the game GTA 6 shares the top critic score with, and its new Switch 2 version took a wave of zero ratings of its own. The user score there fell from 9.6 to about 9.0 within a day. Neither wave tells you anything about either game.
Which Number Means What
The two ratings count different people. Metacritic takes a rating from any registered account and does not check that the account owns the game. Its one brake is a wait of 36 hours after release, in place since 2020. The PlayStation Store only takes ratings from accounts that acquired the game there, and its ratings policy says so in plain words.


Discussion
Comments · User score: 5.6 against a 99
No comments yet.
Loading comments…